Observability Into Your FinOps: Taking Distributed Tracing Beyond Monitoring
Distributed tracing has been growing in popularity as a primary tool for investigating performance issues in microservices systems. Our recent DevOps Pulse survey shows a 38% increase year-over-year in organizations’ tracing use. Furthermore, 64% of those respondents who are not yet using tracing indicated plans to adopt it in the next two years.
However, many organizations have yet to realize just how much potential distributed tracing holds. The fact is, once your application is instrumented, it opens up a whole new world of observability into numerous processes in areas including developer experience, business, and FinOps.
Many articles discuss developer use cases. In this article, I’d like to venture off and explore the less commonly discussed use cases in the business and FinOps realm and the related implications.
Context propagation: the secret sauce behind tracing
At the heart of distributed tracing lies the notion of “trace context” and its propagation through the system. This notion is formalized in the W3C Trace Context specification, and takes a central role in OpenTelemetry context propagation, in OpenTracing and other industry standards. Let’s go over the main concepts:
What is trace context
Trace context is the data required to move trace information across service boundaries. It is a set of globally unique identifiers that represents the unique request, within which each span exists (spans are the individual operations that comprise the full execution flow of that request).
One great aspect of trace context is that it is not bound to a predefined set of data. This means essentially that you can capture any extra user-defined properties that you’d like to monitor from your application (with the right instrumentation), to provide observability of many types. This user-defined data, sometimes called Baggage, could be the URL of an HTTP request, the SQL statement of a database query, or it could be almost anything really.
What is context propagation
Context propagation (sometimes called distributed context propagation) is the process through which the context is bundled and transferred through your distributed application across threads, components, processes, and services. This is typically accomplished via HTTP headers, following the W3C trace context specification. Your instrumentation libraries or auto-instrumentation agents typically take care of the context propagation behind the scenes.
The beauty is that once you’ve got the plumbing in place to propagate context through your application, it opens up a whole world of additional context that you can collect to support more sophisticated observability. To flesh this out, let’s review some interesting use cases from the business and FinOps domain.
Distributed tracing for FinOps and compliance
Companies living in today’s cloud-native world increasingly use shared resources and infrastructure to run their businesses. These resources could include compute, storage, network, or many others. One of the related challenges for these organizations is tracking related resource utilization and attributing it back to the respective business unit or product line. Resource attribution is key for effective FinOps, as it determines the cost structure of a business unit.
Furthermore, in many of today’s SaaS business models, operating multi-tenant systems requires the ability to attribute resource costs to tenants. Furthermore, SaaS businesses typically employ rate limiting for each tenant to avoid impacting the service availability levels of other tenants running on the shared resources. Rate-limiting multi-tenant storage, for instance, is said to save cloud vendors hundreds of millions of dollars per year.
Unfortunately, while backend components are aware of low level resource information such as CPU and memory utilization, they typically lack the high-level context about the business or tenant that triggered the request. Yet, by enlisting distributed tracing, the unique identifier (ID) of that business unit, product, or tenant can be propagated down to the backend and infrastructure. Then it’s just a matter of aggregating resource utilization figures by that ID to get the per-product (or other business entity) utilization.
Resource attribution can also help with internal capacity planning processes. Understanding how much of a resource was consumed by a given product or business line can help plan any required expansion of the involved infrastructure, aligning it with related business growth targets.
Data privacy compliance is another common issue that organizations face, especially in light of GDPR and CCPA. The frequent problem, as before, is that low level storage is often unaware of user context. Distributed tracing can propagate the user ID from the frontend tier downstream to the backend and data storage tiers so that data access can be verified against it to enforce data privacy policies.
From common infrastructure to common practice
As more organizations are instrumenting their applications for monitoring purposes, context propagation is becoming a common infrastructure.
The next step in this evolution is moving from use as a common infrastructure to adoption as a common practice. This movement can be influenced not only by the dev and DevOps teams, but also by stakeholders with oversight of business and FinOps. This, in turn, will create more champions for tracing within the organization, in general, which will accelerate adoption and instrumentation efforts throughout additional parts of the involved systems, and with a more diverse set of data.
Once this practice becomes more common, we may reach the point where incentives beyond today’s monitoring practices could drive organizations to venture into distributed tracing — incentives that bear direct impact on the company’s top or bottom line.
If you find this topic interesting, check out this episode of OpenObservability Talks podcast.
This article originally ran on APMDigest on October 18, 2021 (https://www.apmdigest.com/observability-into-your-finops-taking-distributed-tracing-beyond-monitoring)”
